Construction Technology & Innovation
/
Nov 19, 2026
Engineering Submittal Review Template (Free Download)
A free submittal review template for engineers: spec references, compliance status by item and a response block for returning actions to the contractor.

An engineering submittal review template gives the design team one record for each product data review: the spec paragraph behind every requirement, a compliance status for each item, and a response block that ties every comment to the action the contractor has to take.
The free template below is built backward from that response, so every disposition has row-by-row evidence behind it and the general contractor knows what to fix before the next submission.
That return step is where most construction projects lose time. A "revise and resubmit" goes back with three loose comments, the specialty contractor guesses at what the reviewer meant, and the next cycle starts from page one. Approval delays build up in review cycles that close nothing.
What should an engineering submittal review template include?
An engineering submittal review template should include seven sections: submittal identification, a review scope statement, a characteristic table tied to spec paragraphs, a deviation check, a comment register, a disposition block, and a resubmittal tracker.
Section | What it records |
Submittal identification | Project, submittal number, spec section, submittal type, review cycle (matches the submittal register) |
Review scope statement | What was reviewed, limited to conformance with design intent and the contract documents |
Characteristic table | Spec paragraph, required value, submitted value and page, status (Conforms / Does not conform / Information missing), comment ID |
Deviation and substitution check | Deviations the contractor flagged, plus any found unflagged |
Comment register | Comment ID, page, comment, required contractor action |
Disposition block | Response action, reviewer initials, date |
Resubmittal tracker | Cycle number, IDs closed, IDs open, declared changes |
Download the free engineering submittal review template (Google Sheets / .xlsx).

How is the engineering template different from a contractor review form?
The engineering template records the design team's response, while a contractor's construction submittal review form records the GC's check before transmittal. A construction submittal review template supports contractor review and quality control during submittal preparation and ends with the GC's stamp. The engineering version ends with a response action the contractor can act on.
How do you run a construction submittal review with the template?
You run it in six steps: log the submittal, pull the spec requirements, fill the characteristic table, write numbered comments, set the disposition, and return the package.
Log the submittal against the submittal register. Check the spec section, the submittal type, the contract requirements, and the review deadline. Return unrequired submittal items without action, so they don't sit in the project documentation as unreviewed records.
Pull requirements from the project specifications first. Read the technical specifications and the equipment schedule before opening the submittal.
Fill the table product by product and tag by tag. One product data sheet often covers a dozen VAV tags in different sizes, so give each tag its own rows.
Write each nonconformance as a numbered comment. Keep one issue per comment, tied to a spec paragraph and a submittal page.
Set the disposition from the open rows. Base the stamp on the worst unresolved row.
Return the package and log it. The completed template doubles as the response cover sheet. Send it with the marked-up submittal, then update the submittal log so the project managers and the sub are on the same page.
Submittal review checklist for engineers
Use this submittal review checklist for engineers before the package goes back. Every row of the characteristic table needs:
A spec paragraph or schedule reference
The required value, entered before the submittal was opened
The submitted value with a page number
A status: Conforms, Does not conform, or Information missing
A comment ID if the row doesn't conform
How do engineers document comments a general contractor can act on?
Engineers document submittal review comments best by writing one issue per comment, citing the spec paragraph and the submittal page, and stating the required action. When a comment only says "does not comply," the sub has to guess.
These illustrative examples use common product data gaps:
Weak comment | Strong comment |
"Glazing does not comply." | "C-04: Visible light transmittance submitted at 33% (p. 12). Spec requires 42% minimum. Submit a product that meets 42% VLT." |
"Verify warranty." | "C-07: Warranty term not shown. Spec requires 10 years from substantial completion. Submit the manufacturer's warranty." |
"Coil coating?" | "C-09: Coating listed without a corrosion rating. Spec calls for salt-air coated coils. Submit coating data confirming the rating." |
Wording that keeps comments inside the scope of review
WTW's guidance for design professionals on stamping shop drawings warns against comments that read like instructions to change the design, since submittals can't modify the contract documents. Ask for what the spec already requires ("submit," "provide," "confirm"), and avoid words like "change" or "modify." Dimensions, quantities, and means and methods stay with the responsible contractor.
As Tom Port, co-founder of BuildSync, explains: “‘Does not comply’ might be the most expensive comment in construction. The engineer knows exactly what they meant. They saw 460 volts on the cut sheet when the schedule calls for 208. But by the time that comment reaches the sub, it’s two words on a PDF with no spec section attached. So the sub guesses, fixes one thing, and sends it back. Now you’re on round two and the real issue still isn’t solved. When the comment shows the required value, the submitted value, and the spec paragraph it comes from, the sub can fix it right the first time.”
What response actions can the design team return on construction submittals?
The design team usually returns one of five response actions: Approved (or No Exceptions Taken), Approved as Noted, Revise and Resubmit, Rejected, or Not Required. The contractor reads each one as a yes or no on buying the proposed materials.
Response action | What the contractor does next |
Approved / No Exceptions Taken | Proceeds with procurement and fabrication |
Approved as Noted | Proceeds and complies with each written comment |
Revise and Resubmit | Corrects the listed items and resubmits |
Rejected | Submits a different product or a substitution request |
Not Required | Files it, knowing it wasn't reviewed |
Matching the submittal response template to your contract documents
Credible sources disagree on which word belongs on the stamp:
Source | Position |
EJCDC, Kevin O'Beirne, PE, on submittal review stamps | Softer terms like "No Exceptions Taken" don't reduce liability. Use "Approved" with a clear scope disclaimer. |
WTW guidance for design professionals | Treats "approve" as a word to avoid. |
AIA B101 §3.6.4.2 | The architect reviews submittals only to check conformance with the design concept. |
BuildSync explains the difference between No Exceptions Taken and Approved in more depth. Use your firm's own stamp wording in the submittal response template. When every finding has an ID and a source, the disposition is defensible whichever word your firm uses. Firms usually map open rows like this:
What the open rows show | Disposition |
Every row conforms | Approved or No Exceptions Taken |
Minor issues resolved by following a note, with no effect on the project's design intent | Approved as Noted |
Required information missing, or a correctable nonconformance | Revise and Resubmit |
Wrong product, an unlisted manufacturer, or a substitution sent without a substitution request | Rejected |
See how BuildSync flags every technical characteristic before you write a single comment. Book a demo.
How do you track resubmittals without adding approval delays?
Track resubmittals by carrying comment IDs forward. Require the contractor to answer each open ID in writing, then review the open IDs plus anything the contractor declares as changed. The second cycle starts from the tracker instead of page one of the initial submission.
Cycle | Comments closed | Comments still open | Declared changes |
1 (initial submission) | None | C-04, C-07, C-09 | Not applicable |
2 | C-04, C-07 | C-09 | New glazing product, warranty document added |
3 | C-09 | None | Coil coating data added |
In this illustrative example, cycle 2 covers three comments and two declared changes instead of the full package. If a resubmittal changes something the contractor didn't declare, return it as incomplete.
A resubmittal record for construction managers and the project owner
The tracker also gives the project owner and construction managers a record of approval timelines: which comments were open, when each closed, and on which cycle. On long-lead equipment, that record shows where project delays came from.
Where the template stops in the construction submittal process
You still have to fill the template in. An air handling unit submittal can carry 60 or more technical characteristics, and submittal reviewers have to find each one and compare it against the spec. Two kinds of rows slow that work down:
Values the submittal never states, such as a warranty term or a coating rating
Conflicts where the equipment schedule says one thing and the spec says another
Both need the engineer's judgment, and both are easy to miss late in a long review process.
As Tom Port, co-founder of BuildSync, sees this: An Unknown should be treated as needing further review, rather than an indication of non-compliance. A Fail means we've identified a specific requirement that the submitted product doesn't meet, whereas an Unknown means there's insufficient information to make that determination. To make this easier for engineers, we break Unknowns into clear categories, such as Missing Data or Design Team Review, so they can quickly understand whether additional documentation is needed or whether the issue requires professional engineering judgment.
What AI-powered submittal review adds to contractor review and design team review
BuildSync takes on the extraction work. It breaks each submittal into individual products, separates tags that share a data sheet, and checks every technical characteristic against the plans and specifications:
Template element | BuildSync output |
Characteristic table | Pass, Fail, or Unknown for each characteristic, with the reason |
"Information missing" status | Unknown, when the submittal or spec lacks the information to decide |
Schedule and spec conflicts | Both requirements recorded and the more stringent one identified, so the engineer can decide or issue an RFI |
Completed template | Excel compliance report and a marked-up submittal PDF |
Skepticism about software checking technical documentation is reasonable when an engineer's name is on the response. That's why "See Files" opens the submittal page and the spec page side by side for every finding, and the disposition stays with the engineer. BuildSync also integrates with Procore. The guide to engineering submittal review automation covers the full workflow.

What changes when submittals arrive pre-reviewed
When construction teams on the contractor side run the same review before transmittal, the engineer gets a cleaner package. Monteith Construction reports 70% faster submittal reviews. At Fountain Electric, a roughly 500-page lighting submittal was reviewed in 2 to 3 hours instead of 2 to 3 days. It went to the architect with the BuildSync review sheet and came back Approved as Noted.
As Tom Port, co-founder of BuildSync, puts it: Submittal review can really eat into a firm's CA fee simply because of the sheer amount of time it takes. Engineers can spend hours going through technical documents, pulling out requirements, and checking them against the submitted product data. By automating that manual work, firms can significantly reduce review times and give engineers more time to focus on the decisions that actually require their expertise. That ultimately means fewer hours spent on each submittal and better CA profit margins.
See the template's characteristic table filled in on your own submittal. Book a BuildSync demo, or try it free on a product data package your team is reviewing now.
Engineering submittal review template FAQs
Can the same template be used for shop drawings?
Yes. The characteristic table and comment register work for shop drawings, physical samples, and material samples. BuildSync's automated review covers product data, so shop drawings stay a manual review.
Who should fill out the engineering submittal review template on a construction project?
What's the difference between a submittal review template and a submittal log?
What should an engineer do when a submittal contains an unflagged deviation?
What happens in the approval process when the GC's review stamp is missing?
Related reads for you
Discover more articles that align with your interests and keep exploring.



